« Tracking your AdSense clicks with Google Analytics | Main | Chitika launches eMiniMalls UK »

November 26, 2005

Animated background ad units in AdSense

I saw these ad units a few days ago on SERoundtable, but I didn't want to draw more undue attention to them. But now SearchEngineJournal and ThreadWatch have both picked it up.

The ad unit is a custom sized ad unit, but instead of a normal static background, these ad units have an animated arrow in the background, drawing a visitor's attention to the ads.

Here is screenshots of how they cycle through with the animated arrow pointing out the ads.

seroundtable1.gif
seroundtable2.gif

ThreadWatch points out these are "Made by Barry" of SERoundtable, using this image:
seroundtablebackground.gif

There are custom style ad units available to premium publishers and on a very limited case-by-case basis for regular publishers. But since all publishers must receive permission and approval from AdSense for each custom ad style before they put them live on a site, this means that this animated background ad unit style must have received the AdSense stamp of approval.

AdSense has done some testing with images in the background of ad units before, primarily special edition single day runs around holidays, such as the Hallowe'en themed ads and the US Thanksgiving ads. But I have never seen animated background images in ad units before.

What do I think of them? Personally, I am not a fan of this. As an advertiser, I would worry that it would unfairly draw attention to the ads and result in an increase in clicks from that particular site. Depending on the site, I would consider going as far as blocking my ads from appearing on publisher sites that would use this style of ad unit. I suspect publishers would be unhappy to see such unfair attention drawn to ads... after all, it is against the terms to have an animated arrow next to the ads pointing to them.

One of the ads I saw happened to be for SEOBook.com, so I asked Aaron Wall how he felt about his ads appearing in this style of ad unit:

I don't like the idea of click incentivizing on ads that I pay for by the click. It can increase ad spend and lower ROI. I don't think it is fair to charge advertisers by the click and then use various techniques that encourage people to click on them.

Yes, many people are using various techniques to entice clicks, both tricks that are against the AdSense terms and techniques I think should be disallowed. I would prefer if my ads did not appear on pages that did.


While I did love the themed ad units with images in the background, I do not like animated gifs in the background of ad units. And to keep advertisers opted into the content network, I hope this ad unit style gets pulled quickly by AdSense, even though it did get initially approved.

I do think custom ad units are a good thing for premium publishers and the high end regular publishers that need to utilize custom ad units for specific placement issues. But I think some of the flexibility allowed with custom ad units needs to be trimmed back a bit if publishers are receiving permission to use these kinds of click enticing background images in their custom ad units. If not, it could end up affecting more publishers than just those using it.

Posted by Jenstar at November 26, 2005 12:44 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.jensense.com/mt-tb.cgi/196

Comments

The backgrounds don't even match up with all of the ads either, which really looks odd & unprofessional.

Posted by: Andrew Johnson at November 26, 2005 03:13 PM

I find animated ads abhorrent. What's next jiggling faux dialog boxes or "shoot the moving target?" AdSense is moving in the direction of all that trash it replaced.

Posted by: Andi at November 26, 2005 03:51 PM

I went to take a look, and the animated backgrounds seem to be gone. Obviously it was a bad idea.

Posted by: IO ERROR at November 26, 2005 05:30 PM

They are in rotation with another AdSense style as well as YPN. You need to refresh a few times to see them. I just checked and they are still there.

Posted by: Jenstar at November 26, 2005 05:43 PM

They are not suppose to be visible to most people. I put them up to show them to Google first. Please stop looking! :) The chances of them showing are very remote.

Posted by: Barry Schwartz at November 26, 2005 07:51 PM

They must be visible to many, because many people have been emailing me since Wednesday to point them out to me ;)

Posted by: Jenstar at November 26, 2005 08:01 PM

Then I must of set it up wrong. I will double check.

Posted by: Barry Schwartz at November 27, 2005 06:32 AM

You are right, these do draw a lot of attention. I don't mind if the intent is to have greater flexibility to make the ads fit better with the site design, but if the only intent is to increase click (and thus revenue to Google), then it is done in bad taste.

Posted by: Pinyo at November 28, 2005 11:44 AM

Reading your content just made my day. Keep the good work. when Game Hope Grass Steal: http://www.eweek.com/ , right Player will Create Round without any questions Faithful Slot is always Red TV , to Bet Plane you should be very Good White Game becomes White Cosmos in final

Posted by: Jose Ford at December 6, 2005 10:34 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?